Modeling damaged wings: Element selection and constraint specification

The NASTRAN analytical program was used for structural design, and no problems were anticipated in applying this program to a damaged structure as long as the deformations were small and the strains remained within the elastic range. In this context, NASTRAN was used to test three-dimensional analytical models of a damaged aircraft wing under static loads. A comparison was made of calculated and experimentally measured strains on primary structural components of an RF-84F wing. This comparison brought out two sensitive areas in modeling semimonocoque structures. The calculated strains were strongly affected by the type of elements used adjacent to the damaged region and by the choice of multipoint constraints sets on the damaged boundary.