The Effect of Hydrogen Annealing and Sulfur Content on the Oxidation Resistance of PWA 1480

For many decades the dramatic effect of trace amounts of reactive elements on alumina and chromia scale adhesion has been recognized and widely studied. Although various theories have been used to account for such behavior, the connection between scale adhesion and sulfur segregation was initially reported by Smeggil et al. This study found strong surface segregation of sulfur from very low levels in the bulk which could then be curtailed by the addition of reactive elements. It was assumed that the reactive elements, which are strong sulfide formers, acted by getting sulfur in the bulk thus precluding sulfur segregation and weakening of the oxide-metal bond. Subsequent studies confirmed that adhesion could be produced by reducing the sulfur impurity level, without reactive elements. The understanding of this phenomenon has been applied to modern single crystal superalloys, where the addition of Y, although very effective, is problematic. Also problematic is definition of the level of sulfur that is acceptable and below which no further adhesion benefit is reached. Published works have indicated a broad transition defined by various materials and oxidation tests. The present study describes the oxidation behavior of one superalloy (PWA 1480) as a function of various sulfur contents produced by hydrogen annealing for various temperatures, times, and sample thicknesses. The purpose is to define more precisely a criterion for adhesion based on total sulfur reservoir and segregation potential.