Petrographic Evidence for Rapid Heating and Cooling During Chrondrule Formation

The chondrule cooling rates used in most chondrule-formation models appear to be too low. Recent petrographic evidence indicates that the amount of crystal (especially olivine) growth that occurred after the last melting event was about 30 smaller than the grain sizes simulated in order to estimate cooling rates. The smaller amount of growth leads to an upwards revision of cooling rates by about a factor of 1000. Most chondrules are porphyritic. They consist of large and small crystals of olivine and, less commonly, pyroxene immersed in a mesostasis having a plagioclase-rich composition. In the most primitive chondrites the mesostasis is often vitreous. Because the large majority of chondrules contain FeS, it is clear that the nebula had cooled below the FeS condensation temperature (ca. 650 K) before chondrule formation occurred. The high FeO/(FeO+MgO) ratios of some chondrules require still lower nebular temperatures (less than 500 K). The traditional view has been that porphyritic chondrules formed in a single heating/cooling event and many laboratory experiments have been carried out in various kinds of kinds of furnaces to try to simulate the formation of chondrules textures in a single heating/cooling cycle. These furnace experiments have been used to infer the cooling rates of chondrules during the temperature range at which olivine crystallized from the melt. Most of these inferred values are in the range 0.01-1 K per second. These low cooling rates are problematical because there is no long-term nebular environment that yields such values. In transparent regions chondrules would cool at rates orders of magnitude higher, whereas in an opaque nebular disk the cooling rates would be many orders of magnitude lower. And these latter conditions are not suitable locations for chondrule formation because such high temperatures would cause the complete evaporation of chondrules (which have melting temperatures about 600 K higher than their evaporation temperatures). During the last several years several kinds of petrographic evidence indicating rapid chondrule cooling have been recognized. These include thin overgrowths on relict grains, clusters of small crystals that grew following the most recent melting event, and fragments preserving shardlike shapes that would have been hidden had several tens of micrometers of new growth occurred following the last melting event. And there are other indications of rapid cooling including the preservation of volatiles such as FeS and one case where the modeling of O-isotopic and FeO/(FeO+MgO) gradients indicated a high cooling rate.