Equivalence of equations describing trace element distribution during equilibrium partial melting

It is shown that four equations used for calculating the evolution of trace-element abundances during equilibrium partial melting are mathematically equivalent. The equations include those of Hertogen and Gijbels (1976), Shaw (1970), Schilling (1971), and O'Nions and Clarke (1972). The general form to which all these equations reduce is presented, and an analysis is performed to demonstrate their mathematical equivalence. It is noted that the utility of the general equation flows from the nature of equilibrium (i.e., the final state is independent of the path by which that state is attained).