Stability analysis of a reinforced carbon carbon shell

This paper presents the development of a stability analysis for the nose cap of the NASA Space Shuttle Orbiter. Stability is evaluated by the differential stiffness analysis of the NASTRAN finite-element computer code, addressing those nonstandard characteristics in the nose cap such as nonuniform curvature, asymmetrical and nonuniform loads, support fixity, and various combinations of membrane and bending stresses. A full-sized nose cap, thinner than production, was statically tested and stability analyzed. The failing load level correlated to within 30%. The region and mode of buckling that occurred during test was accurately predicted by analysis. The criterion for predicting instability is based on the behavior of the nonlinear deflections. The deflections are nonlinear elastic in that the stresses are well within the elastic range of the material, but the geometry-load relationship produces nonlinear deflections. The load-deflection relationship is well defined by differential stiffness analysis up to the zero-slope portion of the curve, the point of neutral stability or where the shell 'snaps through' just prior to general instability.