Lunar anorthosite paradox - An alternative explanation

In most lunar terrae samples a trend of decreasing Ab-content of plagioclase with increasing Fa-content of olivine is observed. This covariance of composition is the opposite of the trend observed in terrestrial layered intrusions, and contradicts Bowen's reaction series. The 'anomalous' trend is considered in terms of olivine-melt and plagioclase-melt equilibria. The composition of plagioclase crystallizing from a melt depends directly upon the activity of silica in the melt, while the composition of olivine does not. It is proposed that the inverse correlation of plagioclase and olivine compositions in most lunar terrae rocks is a predictable consequence of crystallization from a lunar bulk composition which is poorer in silica than the bulk compositions of terrestrial layered intrusions. The data of Roedder and Weiblen (1974) lend support to this hypothesis.