Carbon in the Allende meteorite - Evidence for poorly graphitized carbon rather than carbyne

A carbon-rich acid residue from the Allende carbonaceous chondrite was examined by high-resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM) and also by analytical electron microscopy. A TEM mount of this residue that has previously been reported to contain carbyne forms of carbon was shown to contain sheet silicate contaminants. These sheet silicate grains give electron diffraction patterns similar to those reported for carbynes, thus raising questions about the previous report of carbynes in this residue. Furthermore, two crystals from a glacier microspherule, which had previously been identified as carbyne VIII, were shown by microanalysis to be talc. In view of these observations it is suggested that identifications of carbyne by electron diffraction should be supported by microanalyses of the individual grains. HRTEM investigations of the Allende carbon indicate that it is a poorly crystalline graphite, structurally similar to 'glassy' carbon