Problems with the process partitioning theory of stratocumulus entrainment

Three different approaches to partitioning were proposed. Ball (1960), Lilly (1968), and Deardorff et al. (1969, 1974) considered the sign of the net buoyancy flux at each level. If the net flux is positive, it is counted as TKE producing; otherwise, it is counted as TKE consuming. This approach can be called Eulerian partitioning. The second approach can be called process partitioning. It is assumed that the various processes acting in concert each produce and consume the same energy as if they acted independently (Manins and Turner, 1978). The total rates of TKE production and consumption are obtained by summing the effects of all the forcing processes. The third approach is Lagrangian partitioning. Each air parcel is considered as either producing or consuming TKE, according to the sign of the product of its density and vertical velocity anomalies. Stage and Businger (1981a,b) have applied process partitioning to the cloud topped mixed layer. One of the most important processes influencing entrainment into such a layer is cloud top radiative cooling. The production and consumption due to entrainment and radiative cooling are thus closely related. Model results are sensitive to the choice of formulation.