A geometric derivation of Kane's equations

A geometrically-based derivation of Kane's dynamical equations is presented. Equations for both holonomic and nonholonomic systems are derived by considering the system's motion in a hypersurface determined from the equations relating Cartesian to generalized coordinates. Using vector space methods, the equations of motion are projected onto the tangent plane to the hypersurface. In the course of this construction, a requirement on the transformation between generalized and Cartesian coordinates is revealed that is often overlooked. This restriction is then shown to be a necessary and sufficient condition for the invertibility of the coefficient matrix of the generalized accelerations appearing in Kane's dynamical equations. Although less succinct than the traditional approach, the present derivation offers some insight into the physics embodied in Kane's equations and appears as a natural generalization of methods used in elementary problems.