Comment on 'Distribution of whistler mode bursts at Venus' by F.L. Scarf, K.F. Jordan, and C.T. Russell

Consideration is given to the study of the 100-Hz electric field noise observed from the Pioneer Venus Orbiter (PVO) by Scarf et al. (1987). It is suggested that the study incorrectly interprets the results as evidence for lightning and volcanism at Venus. Statistical evidence is presented, suggesting that the distribution of the noise is essentially random, within the zone of occurrence of ion troughs, and decreases at the lowest PVO altitudes, closest to the neutral atmosphere. It is found that the topographic clustering reported by Scarf et al. is an artifact of the variable spatial distribution of troughs and associated noise.