Carbon in the outer solar system

The satellites of Uranus, with densities between 1.3 and 1.7 g cm(-3) (from Voyager 2 observations) and the Pluto-Charon system, with a mean density of just above 1.8 g cm(-3) (from terrestrial observations of mutual eclipse events), are too dense to have a significant amount of methane ice in their interiors. However, the observed densities do not preclude contributions from such organic materials as the acid-insoluble residue in carbonaceous chondrites and laboratory-produced tholins, which have densities on the order of approximately 1.5 g cm(-3). These and other considerations have led researchers to investigate the carbon mass budget in the outer solar system, with an emphasis on understanding the contribution of organic materials. Modeling of the interiors of Pluto and Charon (being carried out by R. Reynolds and A. Summers of NASA/Ames), assuming rock and water ice as the only constituents, suggests a silicate mass fraction for this system on the order of 0.65 to 0.70. The present work includes the most recent estimates of the C/H enhancements and high z/low z ratios of the giant planets (Pollack and Bodenheimer, 1987), and involves a more careful estimation of the high z/low z mass ratio expected from solar abundances than was used in Pollack et al. (1986), including the influence of the fraction of C in CO on the amount of condensed water ice. These calculations indicate that for a particular fraction of C in CO and a given fraction of C-bearing planetesimals that dissolve in the envelope (most likely in the range 0.50 to 0.75), (1) Jupiter and Saturn require a larger fraction of C in condensed materials than Uranus and Neptune, but (2) the Jupiter and Saturn results are much less strongly constrained by the error bars on the observed C/H enhancements and high z/low z ratios than is the case for Uranus and Neptune. The clearest result is that in the region of the solar nebula near Uranus and Neptune, the minority of carbon that is not in gaseous CO (1) must include a nonzero amount of condensed material, but (2) is most likely not condensed material alone, i.e., there must be a third carbon-bearing component besides condensed material and gaseous CO. Given the implied dearth of methane ice, the condensed carbon is likely dominated by organic material, and the third component present in addition to CO and organics is assumed to be CH4 gas.