Surface reflectance retrieval from satellite and aircraft sensors - Results of sensors and algorithm comparisons during FIFE

Visible to shortwave infrared radiometric data collected by a number of remote sensing instruments on aircraft and satellite platforms were compared over common areas in the First International Satellite Land Surface Climatology Project (ISLSCP) Field Experiment (FIFE) site on August 4, 1989, to assess their radiometric consistency and the adequacy of atmospheric correction algorithms. The instruments in the study included the Landsat 5 Thematic Mapper (TM), the SPOT 1 high-resolution visible (HRV) 1 sensor, the NS001 Thematic Mapper simulator, and the modular multispectral radiometers (MMRs). Atmospheric correction routines analyzed were an algorithm developed for FIFE, LOWTRAN 7, and 5S. A comparison between corresponding bands of the SPOT 1 HRV 1 and the Landsat 5 TM sensors indicated that the two instruments were radiometrically consistent to within about 5 percent. Retrieved surface reflectance factors using the FIFE algorithm over one site under clear atmospheric conditions indicated a capability to determine near-nadir surface reflectance factors to within about 0.01 at a reflectance of 0.06 in the visible (0.4-0.7 microns) and about 0.30 in the near infrared (0.7-1.2 microns) for all but the NS001 sensor. All three atmospheric correction procedures produced absolute reflectances to within 0.005 in the visible and near infrared. In the shortwave infrared (1.2-2.5 microns) region the three algorithms differed in the retrieved surface reflectances primarily owing to differences in predicted gaseous absorption. Although uncertainties in the measured surface reflectance in the shortwave infrared precluded definitive results, the 5S code appeared to predict gaseous transmission marginally more accurately than LOWTRAN 7.