An evaluation of three spatial differencing schemes for the discrete ordinates method in participating media

Three popular spatial differencing schemes for the discrete ordinates method are examined for two-dimensional Cartesian coordinates system. These are a positive, the step, and the diamond schemes. Contrary to the common belief that negative intensities will not occur when fine spatial discretization is used with the diamond scheme, under certain conditions, the diamond scheme will produce negative intensities irrespective of the number of control volums employed. The positive scheme can produce physically unrealistic trends. The diamond and positive schemes are also capable of producing physically unrealistic overshoots. In absorbing-emitting or absorbing-emitting-scattering media, grid refinement can result in negative intensities when the diamond or positive scheme is used.