A different view of plasma flow inside P/Halley

The Giotto spacecraft carried two different instruments - the JPA and the IMS - for the observation of hot ions in the coma of P/Halley. Although there are many similarities in the time and distance profiles of the plasma flow parameters (bulk velocity, number density, and temperature) computed from the two data sets, there are also some significant differences, especially at cometocentric distances less than 500,000 km. The principal discrepancies between the JPA results presented by Formisano et al. (1990) and the IMS observations are: (1) the IMS did not detect the levelling off of the speed and temperature profiles that Formisano et al. interpreted as flow stabilization; (2) the IMS detected differential north-south flow between the solar wind and cometary ions for only a brief interval when the magnetic field was oriented nearly southward, whereas Formisano et al. reported more extensive differential north-south flow that was independent of the direction of the field; (3) the JPA ion densities were factors of 2 to 4 higher than the IMS ion densities which, in turn, were an order of magnitude greater than theoretical values.