Presence of Mind... A Reaction to Sheridan's "Musing on Telepresence"

What are the benefits and significance of developing a scientifically useful measure of the human sense of presence in an environment? Such a scale could be conceived to measure the extent to which users of telerobotics interfaces feel or behave as if they were present at the site of a remotely controlled robot. The essay examines some issues raised in order to identify characteristics, a scale of 'presence' ought to have to be useful as an explanatory scientific concept. It also addresses the utility of worrying about developing such a scale at all. To be useful in the same manner as a traditional scientific concept such as mass, for example, it is argued that such scales not only need to be precisely defined and co-vary with determinative factors but also need to establish equivalence classes of its independent constituents. This simplifying property is important for either subjective or objective scales of presence and arises if the constituents of presence are truly independent.