Metrics for Linear Kinematic Features in Sea IceThe treatment of leads as cracks or discontinuities (see Coon et al. presentation) requires some shift in the procedure of evaluation and comparison of lead-resolving models and their validation against observations. Common metrics used to evaluate ice model skills are by and large an adaptation of a least square "metric" adopted from operational numerical weather prediction data assimilation systems and are most appropriate for continuous fields and Eilerian systems where the observations and predictions are commensurate. However, this class of metrics suffers from some flaws in areas of sharp gradients and discontinuities (e.g., leads) and when Lagrangian treatments are more natural. After a brief review of these metrics and their performance in areas of sharp gradients, we present two new metrics specifically designed to measure model accuracy in representing linear features (e.g., leads). The indices developed circumvent the requirement that both the observations and model variables be commensurate (i.e., measured with the same units) by considering the frequencies of the features of interest/importance. We illustrate the metrics by scoring several hypothetical "simulated" discontinuity fields against the lead interpreted from RGPS observations.
Document ID
20070010008
Acquisition Source
Headquarters
Document Type
Conference Paper
Authors
Levy, G. (NorthWest Research Associates, Inc. Bellevue, WA, United States)
Coon, M. (NorthWest Research Associates, Inc. Bellevue, WA, United States)
Sulsky, D. (New Mexico Univ. Albuquerque, NM, United States)