Nd-142/Nd-144 in bulk planetary reservoirs, the problem of incomplete mixing of interstellar components and significance of very high precision Nd-145/Nd-144 measurements

Apart from the challenge of very high precision Nd-142/Nd-144 ratio measurement, accurate applications of the coupled Sm-(146,147)-Nd-(142,143) systematics in planetary differentiation studies require very precise knowledge of the present-day (post-Sm-146 decay) Nd-142/Nd-144 ratios of bulk planetary objects (BP). The coupled systematics yield model ages for the time of formation of Sm/Nd-fractionated reservoirs by differentiation of Sm/Nd-unfractionated bulk planetary reservoirs. Estimates of (Nd-142/Nd-144)(sub BP) and (Nd-143/Nd-144)(sub BP) therefore provide the critical baseline relative to which these model ages are referenced. In the Sm-147-Nd-143 systematics, Nd-143/Nd-144 variations are mostly large; therefore, small variations in initial Nd-143/Nd-144 ratios generally can be ignored. However, in the case of Sm-146-Nd-142, the range of Nd-142/Nd-144 divergence for differentiated planetary reservoirs is much smaller. Consequently Sm-(146,147)-Nd-(142,143) model ages are sensitive to small variations in bulk planetary Nd-142/Nd-144 (both present-day and initial). One major unanswered question is whether or not Nd shelf standards (CIT Nd beta/Ames metal, La Jolla, NASA-JSC/Ames metal) have Nd-142/Nd-144 identical to the bulk Earth or otherwise might record some degree of radiogenic evolution in an early-fractionated reservoir. Our discussions of earth Earth differentiation based on Nd-142/Nd-144 in Isua and Acasta samples have employed a working assumption: (Nd-142/Nd-144)(sub Nd beta) = (Nd-142/Nd-144)(sub Bulk Earth). This requires experimental justification and is apparently contradicted by chondrite Nd-142/Nd-144 measurements, which have been interpreted to indicate: (Nd-142/Nd-144)(sub JSC/Ames metal) = ((Nd-142/Nd-144)(sub CHUR) = 35 plus or minus 8 ppm). At present, interpretations of the early Earth and Moon hinge largely on this issue. Because Ba in bulk chondrite samples exhibit similar magnitude nuclear anomalies, attributable to incomplete mixing of interstellar components, a critical question is whether or not nuclear effects are also present in Nd-142/Nd-144, both in bulk chondrites and between planetary objects.