A method of hardware qualification for flight by analyses, similarity and integrated testing

The results are described of a study on four pieces of flight hardware from the Saturn 1U and S-4B stages to determine whether the objectives of the formal qualification tests on that hardware could have been obtained within that program by methods other than performing the qualification tests. These methods include qualification by analyses, similarity and integrated testing, i.e., distribution of the objectives among the other tests in the program. It was found that it is feasible to delete the requirements for formal qualification testing provided that it is accomplished early in the program to allow adequate planning for accomplishing the qualification objectives by other means. Additionally, a scorekeeping system was defined that is simple, straightforward, easy to implement. This scorekeeping system provides complete visibility of equivalent qualification status at any point during the program. A set of groundrules for implementing this study was established as a result of findings on the specific items of hardware studied.