Preliminary design of composite wings for buckling, strength and displacement constraints

An unstiffened panel buckling constraint for balanced, symmetric laminated composites is included on the global design level in a mathematical programming structural optimization procedure for designing wing structures. Constraints are introduced by penalty functions, and Newton's method based on approximate second derivatives of the penalty terms is used as the search algorithm to obtain minimum-mass designs. Constraint approximations used during the optimization process contribute to the computational efficiency of the procedure. A criterion is developed that identifies the appropriate conservative form of the constraint approximations that are used with the optimization procedure. Minimum-mass design results are obtained for a multispar high-aspect-ratio wing subjected to material strength, minimum-gage, displacement, panel buckling and twist constraints. The material systems considered for the examples are all graphite-epoxy, graphite-epoxy with boron-epoxy spar caps, and all aluminum. The composite material designs are shown to have an advantage over the aluminum designs since they can often satisfy additional constraints with only small mass increases.