Umbral oscillations in sunspots

Contrary to the claim by von Uexkuell et al. (1983), their observations of upward phase propagation of umbral oscillations in the chromosphere are in agreement with the photospheric resonance theory of Thomas and Scheuer (1982) and in contradiction to the chromospheric resonance theory of Zhugzhda et al. (1983). Other observational evidence also indicates that the fundamental 3-min umbral oscillation is due to a photospheric resonance, although the closely-spaced multiple peaks sometimes seen in the power spectrum of chromospheric oscillations may well be due to chromospheric resonances.