Multiple Equilibria of the Barotropic Vorticity Equation on a Sphere

Multiple states of the barotropic vorticity equation in which the balance is between the first and third terms on the r.h.s. of (1) are given. Solutions of this type were also considered by Charney and Devore (1979) in their discussion of thermally, rather than topographically, forced waves. Whereas in the case of topographic forcing the multiplicity arises from what they called form-drag instability in the wave-zonal flow interaction, in the thermal forcing case the associated instability appears to be the Rossby-wave instability discussed by Lorenz (1972), and the multiple states of the highly truncated model proved to be unstable when more degrees of freedom were added. The multiple statistically steady solutions described are thus novel in that they do not involve form-drag instability, they have stable statistics in calculations with a large number of degrees of freedoms, and they occur on the sphere, with no artificial confinement in a resonant cavity. Furthermore, the solutions are obtained with no external forcing of the zonal flow. The full non-linear equations for two-dimensional non-divergent motion between smooth, rigid boundaries on a sphere were used.