A comparison of smooth specimen and analytical simulation techniques for notched members at elevated temperatures

Experimental strain measurements have been made at the highly strained regions on notched plate specimens that were made of Hastelloy X. Tests were performed at temperatures up to 1,600 F. Variable load patterns were chosen so as to produce plastic and creep strains. Were appropriate, notch root stresses were experimentally estimated by subjecting a smooth specimen to the measured notch root strains. The results of three analysis techniques are presented and compared to the experimental data. The most accurate results were obtained from an analysis procedure that used a smooth specimen and the Neuber relation to simulate the notch root stress-strain response. When a generalized constitutive relation was used with the Neuber relation, good results were also obtained, however, these results were not as accurate as those obtained when the smooth specimen was used directly. Finally, a general finite element program, ANYSIS, was used which resulted in acceptable solutions, but, these were the least accurate predictions.