The reality of the secular change in solar wind nitrogen isotopes

Evidence concerning the isotopic composition of N in the early solar system currently seems to favor a picture of isotopic inhomogeneity rather than of a unique primordial composition modified by local processes. Certainly the range of N-15/N-14 ratios found in meteorites points to the existence of more than one nucleogenetic N component, though mass dependent modification of them explain the isotopic variation observed for N in the lunar regolith. The observational evidence is addressed which can be used to discriminate between such a model and one invoking a secular change in the composition of the solar wind. Three tests of this model were considered, starting with a search for light planetary N surviving in lunar rocks. Results so far are negative. The results of these tests may not eliminate the two component model for regolith N but they seriously weaken it. The alternate view, involving a secular change in solar wind N composition, has its problems but continues to survive by default.