Vortex breakdown in an axisymmetric flow

The breakdown for both an isolated vortex and a vortex flow in a tube is studied by means of a numerical solution of the axisymmetric Navier-Stokes equations for an unsteady, incompressible, and laminar flow. Results are compared to those of other authors and to experiments. Various numerical solution methods and various physical boundary conditions are used in order to explain the existence of different solutions. The computational results reveal that the existence of different solutions is due to slightly different inflow conditions. The numerical problem for the isolated vortex becomes ill-posed at a certain time for the inflow condition of zero axial gradient of the radial velocity component. Different inflow conditions yield breakdown flowfields containing different features of the experimentally observed breakdown structure.