On the parallel efficiency of the Frederickson-McBryan multigrid

To take full advantage of the parallelism in a standard multigrid algorithm requires as many processors as points. However, since coarse grids contain fewer points, most processors are idle during the coarse grid iterations. Frederickson and McBryan claim that retaining all points on all grid levels (using all processors) can lead to a superconvergent algorithm. The purpose of this work is to show that the parellel superconvergent multigrid (PSMG) algorithm of Frederickson and McBryan, though it achieves perfect processor utilization, is no more efficient than a parallel implementation of standard multigrid methods. PSMG is simply a new and perhaps simpler way of achieving the same results.