Corrosion Prevention in Copper Combustion Chamber Liners of Liquid Oxygen/Methane Booster Engines

Prior research conducted by United Technologies Research Center and Rockwell International Rocketdyne Division encountered severe copper corrosion while flowing hydrocarbon fuels through copper cooling tubes. These experimental results have very important implications for the development of low-cost, regeneratively cooled, oxygen/hydrocarbon bipropellant booster engines.

Aerojet TechSystems undertook a program sponsored by NASA/Lewis Research Center in 1986 with two objectives:
(1) to define the corrosive interaction process that occurs between hydrocarbon fuels and copper combustion chamber liner materials, using both static and dynamic test methods, and (2) to identify and demonstrate protective measures against this corrosive process.

The results of the first program task demonstrated that the most damaging corrosive process was caused by trace amounts of sulfur-containing impurities in the hydrocarbon fuel which react with the copper chamber liner material to form cuprous sulfide (Cu2S), as reported in Paper No. AlAA 88-3215. Experiments were conducted which demonstrated this corrosive process with Mil-Spec RP-1, propane, and methane fuels in contact with OFHC, NASA-Z, and ZrCu coppers.

The preliminary results of the second program task demonstrated that electrodeposited gold and platinum coatings held promise of preventing corrosion of copper chamber liners by methane contaminated with sulfur-containing impurities, as reported in Paper No. AIAA 89-2738. Experiments were conducted which demonstrated greatly reduced corrosion of copper by hydrogen sulfide (H2S) and methyl mercaptan (CH3SH) as measured impurities in methane.

This paper presents the concluding, confirmatory results from the second program task. The efficacy of a protective gold coating on NASA-Z copper cooling channel walls was conclusively demonstrated.

Tests were conducted in the Aerojet Carbothermal Test Facility which provide realistic simulations of booster engine cooling channel conditions such as temperature, pressure, flow velocity, and heat flux. Dynamic test series were performed with methane containing 5 and 10 ppm (by volume) hydrogen sulfide. Gold-plated and unplated copper alloy specimens were evaluated. The tests demonstrated that gold coatings were effective in preventing corrosion of the copper. Posttest metallographic examinations of the unplated specimens showed severe corrosion as a result of reaction with the sulfur containing contaminant in the fuel. In contrast, posttest metallographic examination of the gold-coated specimens showed no corrosion under similar operating conditions.

The findings from metallurgical and chemical analyses of the copper specimens, chemical analysis of the methane, and description of all test conditions are provided. Conclusions are reached as to the efficacy of the plating methods and the effectiveness of the metal coatings in the prevention of corrosion in hydrocarbon-fueled booster engine combustion chamber liners.