Comment on porosities of ice films used to simulate stratospheric cloud surfaces

Reference is made to a recent article by Hanson and Ravishankara (HR) containing data on the reaction probabilities of N2O5 and ClONO2 on ice films of varying thickness. In accordance with their interpretation of the observations, no correction for internal diffusion was needed and, thus, by implication, their films were effectively nonporous. Here, it is argued that vapor deposited films can be highly porous and that porous films do not always show a large increase in reactivity or uptake capacity with thickness. It is pointed out that the assumptions made by HR are responsible for the poor fit of their data.