Potassium isotope cosmochemistry, volatile depletion and the origin of the Earth

We report the first results obtained by our techniques for the precise and accurate determination of the isotopic composition of potassium to constrain the mechanism of volatile element depletion in the formation of the Earth, Moon, and meteorites. Our measurements of delta(K-41) for six chondrites and ten terrestrial rocks attained an average precision of the individual measurement of plus or minus 0.4 percent (2 sigma; plus or minus 0.2 percent/a.m.u. and yield a net chondrite-Earth difference unresolved at the 99 percent confidence limit, delta(K-41) = 0.32 plus or minus 0.35 percent (3 delta). This sets a firm upper limit of 1.3 plus or minus 1.4 percent Rayleigh evaporation of terrestrial potassium (using alpha = square root of 41/39), compared with an observed approximately equals 85 percent chemical depletion of K relative to C1 chondrites. Similar conclusions are reached for the SNC meteorites, Shergotty and Zagami, for 15495 (lunar mare gabbro), and for the eucrite Juvinas. Our conclusion is that direct evaporation of volatile elements from planets (e.g. from silicate vapor atmospheres following giant impact) can be ruled out, and the cause of volatile loss must be sought elsewhere, e.g. nebular processes. Our present findings do not support the conclusions of Hinton et al., the discrepancy to be resolved at a later date. We also find lunar soil 64801, delta(K-41) = +4.99 plus or minus 0.53 percent, to be distinctly heavy in accord with Garner et al.