Volatiles in the Earth: All shallow and all recycled

A case can be made that accretion of the Earth was a high-temperature process and that the primordial Earth was dry. A radial zone-refining process during accretion may have excluded low-melting point and volatile material, including large-ion lithophile elements toward the surface, leaving a refractory and zoned interior. Water, sediments and altered hydrous oceanic crust are introduced back into the interior by subduction, a process that may be more efficient today than in the past. Seismic tomography strongly suggests that a large part of the uppermantle is above the solidus, and this implies wet melting. The mantle beneath Archean cratons has very fast seismic velocities and appears to be strong to 150 km or greater. This is consistent with very dry mantle. It is argued that recycling of substantial quantities of water occurs in the shallow mantle but only minor amounts recycle to depths greater than 200 km. Recycling also oxidizes that mantle; ocean island ('hotspot') basalts are intermediate in oxidation state to island-arc and midocean ridge basalts (MORB). This suggests a deep uncontaminated reservoir for MORB. Plate tectonics on a dry Earth is discussed in order to focus attention on inconsistencies in current geochemical models of terrestrial evolution and recycling.