Comparisons of the Solutions for the Category 3--Problem 2: Cascade-Gust Interaction

Six different solutions were submitted for this benchmark problem. These were obtained using a variety of methods that can be conveniently categorized in two main groups, a nonlinear time-domain group and a linearized frequency-domain group. The first includes solutions submitted by (1) Hixon, (2) Nallasamy et. al, (3) Shieh et. al, and (4) Wang et. al, and the second includes solutions submitted by (5) Coupland and (6) Serrano et. al. Methods (1) and (2) use sixth order compact differencing schemes and the rest are essentially second order in space. With the exception of the solution submitted by Shieh et. al, all are individually discussed in great detail in the workshop proceedings. Comparisons of the submitted solutions with the benchmark solution are presented below. Due to differences in the level of solution detail provided to the author by the participants, the comparisons do not always include results from all submissions. It should be noted at the outset that, since the benchmark solution itself was numerically computed, the comparisons are somewhat subjective. In order to provide maximum latitude for the participants of the workshop, no restrictions were placed on the type of method that could be used to solve the problem. Neither was there were any stipulations to use a particular grid topology or grid density. Therefore, without a detailed study of the critical features of the computed solutions, it is not possible to make concrete statements about the relative merits of one method over another. Such a study is beyond the scope of the current exercise, especially since complete flowfield details were not provided to the author by all participants. Instead a package, containing the information about the benchmark solution (both the steady and unsteady parts of it), is included on the proceedings CD should the authors who submitted solutions for this problem wish to examine in detail the benchmark solution and compare their results to it.