A Minimax Network Flow Model for Assessing Global Impacts of Congestion Management in Transport Systems

The operation of some networks, such as air transportation networks, can be complicated by congestion through a small subset of nodes. The congestion may be influenced by the connectivity of the network, or by the presence of constraints restricting the flow through particular nodes. This work investigates the effects of both connectivity and node flow constraints on the operation of a network. We develop the Minimax Node Load Problem (MNLP), a multicommodity flow model which minimizes the worst-case flow through any node in a given input network. The optimal solution to this problem provides us with the minimax node load, which we propose as a measure of network congestion. Keeping the number of nodes fixed, we first increase connectivity in a series of networks, and observe that topologies with more distributed connections result in a reduction in the minimax node load. However, when connectivity is increased further, the reductions diminish and are accompanied by solutions with undesirable qualities such as longer commodity paths. We then perform a second set of experiments over the same network, constraining flow through different subsets of nodes at different magnitudes of flow restriction, finding that (1) more constrained nodes lead to the largest increases in minimax node load and (2) constraints on the most connected nodes have the greatest effect on both congestion and commodity path length.