Space and Earth Terminal Sizing for Future Mars Missions

NASA is investigating potential communications architectures to support future missions to Mars, with a time horizon out to about 2040. We examined a wide range of Earth-surface, Earth-orbiting, Mars-orbiting, and Mars-landed assets with both radio frequency and optical capabilities, and estimated the size, weight, power, and comparative cost of spacecraft telecommunications subsystems along with their comparative costs. Link attributes needed to achieve a fixed set of desired data rate capabilities were derived, assuming a planned set of Earth stations. For the trunk link from Mars to Earth, the required return data rates considered were 50, 75, 125, and 250 Mbps, and the required forward data rates considered were 30 and 50 Mbps. For proximity links, the required forward and return data rates (symmetric) ranged from 0.36 Mbps to 100 Mbps. The communication channels considered were UHF (75 cm wavelength) for proximity links only, and X-band (3.6 cm wavelength), Kaband (0.81 cm wavelength), and optical (808, 976, 1064, and 1550 nm wavelength) for both proximity and trunk links. Optical solutions provided substantial size and spectrum constraint advantages, but mixed advantages and disadvantages on mass and power. System cost was lower if the RF capability of space assets was increased to permit the number of arrayed RF Earth stations to be limited to two.