Comparison of the CALIPSO Level 3 Ice Cloud Product with the DARDAR and 2C-ICE products

Understanding the vertical distribution of ice clouds is crucial for climate modeling and weather forecasting. Since its launch to space in 2006, the Cloud-Aerosol Lidar with Orthogonal Polarization instrument (CALIOP) onboard the CALIPSO spacecraft has been providing unprecedented high-quality profiles of ice clouds, especially optically thin cirrus clouds, during both day and night, on a global scale. Recently the lidar science working group at the NASA Langley Research Center delivered a level 3 (L3) ice cloud product which reports monthly statistics of ice cloud extinction coefficient and ice water content on a uniform 3-dimensional spatial grid. This presentation compares the ice cloud climatology derived from this product with two other ice cloud products, namely the raDAR/liDAR(DARDAR) ice cloud product and the CloudSat-CALIPSO Ice Cloud Property Product (2C-ICE). Using processing similar to the CALIPSO L3 product, granules of DARDAR and 2C-ICE data have been processed into monthly statistics for a better comparison. Similarities and differences will be presented and discussed. The findings illustrate the strengths of the different products and help to identify which product might be most appropriate for a given research topic.