The oxidation state of sulfur in lunar apatites in meteorites versus Apollo rocks

Sulfur can be present in apatite mineral grains as S6+ [1], S2- [2], or a mixture of the two [3, 4]. The proportion of S6+ to S2- present in the apatite is thought to be predominantly controlled by the prevailing oxygen fugacity (fO2) conditions during crystallization (along with temperature, pressure, and
major element composition; [2-4]). Measurements of apatites and proximal residual glass in the lunar basalts 12039 and 10044 by X-ray absorption near-edge structure (XANES) spectroscopy show that sulfur occurs as S2- in both the mesostasis glass and apatite when measurements are performed far from cracks or pits in the thin section [2], consistent with other mineralogical indications of low fO2 (∆IW-1) during petrogenesis. However, analyses of apatite grains in both samples that were acquired near cracks or pits in the thin section sometimes revealed minor but nonnegligible spectral evidence for the presence of S6+ (e.g., S6+/ΣS > 0.03; [2]). This evidence was interpreted as either primary S2- altered to S6+ in the thin section, or S6+ of secondary origin, deposited in the fractures of the samples [2, 5]. It is unknown whether this alteration is lunar or terrestrial in origin, with implications for lunar petrogenesis if lunar [e.g., 5], or sample handling and curation if terrestrial [e.g., 6].

Note: Extended abstract on document.