Evaluating SAR Radiometric Terrain Correction Solutions: Optimal products for applied users

Operational applications of Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) are under development around the world, driven by the regularly-acquired, free-and-open source C-band SAR observations provided by ESA’s Sentinel-1 sensor constellation since 2014. Groups like SERVIR, a joint NASA and USAID initiative, are at the forefront of remote sensing applications for societal benefit. A takeaway from SERVIR’s experience is the need for appropriately geocoded and fully calibrated SAR data that is ready to use for a range of ecosystems-related applications. Radiometric Terrain Corrected (RTC) data are key entry-level products for multiple applications that range from ecosystems to hazards. This work fills a gap in current research by evaluating several RTCs produced by open-source software solutions (SNAP-7 and ISCE-2), the gold standard commercial software (GAMMA), a Google Earth Engine (GEE) based workflow, and the uncorrected GRD products currently available in GEE. RTCs were analyzed for geolocation quality, absolute radiometric calibration, and fidelity of the radiometric terrain flattening over ten sites representing varied terrains. In addition, a time series analysis was conducted over two locations. Overall, no significant differences for radiometric calibration were found across RTC products. However, all RTCs performed better than uncorrected GRD products. The main differences between products were found in geolocation quality. These results not only demonstrate the need for the uptake and distribution of RTC products for ecosystems applications, but demonstrate the ability to do so with open source methods, adding value to developing affordable operational applications.