Re-Computation of Numerical Results Contained in NACA Report No. 741

This paper presents recomputed theoretical results and compares those results with original results contained in NACA Report No. 741 (NACA 741), “Flutter Calculations in Three Degrees of Freedom,” by Theodore Theodorsen and I.E. Garrick. The recomputations were performed employing the solution method described in NACA 741 but using modern computational tools. With some exceptions, the magnitudes and trends of the original results were in good-to-excellent agreement with the recomputed results, a surprising but gratifying result considering that the NACA 741 results were computed “by hand” using pencil, paper, slide rules, and mechanical calculators called comptometers. Checks on the recomputations (about 25% to 30% were checked) were performed using the so-called k-method of flutter solution. In all cases, including those where the original and recomputed results differed significantly, the checks were in excellent agreement with the recomputed results.