Variations in Apatite F, Cl, and OH Abundances in Primitive Achondrites: Evidence of Fractional Melting?

The apatite group minerals [Ca5(PO4)3(F,Cl,OH)] are some of the primary mineralogical reservoirs for phosphorus on Earth and a common phosphate mineral within a broad range of extraterrestrial samples. Naturally occurring apatite hosts F, Cl, and OH as essential structural constituents, and all three make up the apatite endmembers fluorapatite, chlorapatite, and hydroxylapatite, respectively. Although apatite is one of the most common phosphate minerals in meteorites and rocks from Earth, it typically occurs at minor to trace abundances. Apatite has been widely used as a mineralogical tool to probe the interiors of both differentiated and undifferentiated parent bodies for information about volatiles; however, little work has been done on apatite F, Cl, and OH abundances of apatite from primitive achondrite meteorites.

There are broad differences between apatite X-site chemistry in chondrite parent bodies (typically F-poor) compared to apatite from basaltic rocks from many achondrite parent bodies (Cl-poor, apart from Mars). These differences could indicate that planetary differentiation processes, namely melting, play an important role in the evolution of apatite X-site chemistry. In fact, some ordinary chondrite meteorites that exhibit evidence of minor impact melting have apatite with X-site compositions that are much more F-rich than typical chondrite apatite. McCubbin et al., hypothesized that the F-rich compositions of the apatite in ordinary chondrites affected by impact melting could be the result of apatite partially melting, driving the residual apatite to more F-rich compositions; however, they also indicated that degassing of the more volatile Cl and H may also contribute to the F-enrichment.

To further test the partial melting hypothesis, we investigate the F, Cl, and OH (by difference) abundances of apatite from primitive achondrite parent bodies given that they are thought to come from partially differentiated parent bodies that represent residues after partial melting. Consequently, their apatites could provide valuable insights into the effects of melting on apatite X-site chemistry. In this study, we report F and Cl abundances of apatite from a broad array of primitive achondrite meteorites, and we develop a model for apatite fractional melting using known apatite-melt partitioning relationships. Together, we use these results to further elucidate the role of melting on apatite X-site compositions.