Development of a Combined Cohesive and Virtual Crack-Closure Technique Approach to Represent R-Curves

Resistance curve (R-curve) effects due to fiber bridging, crack migration, and other blunting mechanisms are common in composite laminates. These mechanisms can dramatically increase the resistance to crack propagation but can be challenging to simulate. Delamination with R-curves can be analyzed using cohesive zone modeling (CZM) or the virtual crack closure technique (VCCT). Large fracture process zones can be simulated with CZM, but they require highly refined meshes. Coarser meshes can be used with VCCT, but this method is only applicable to small fracture process zones with R-curves defined as functions of position. Therefore, a technique with the computational efficiency of VCCT and the natural ability of cohesive elements to represent large fracture process zones is desirable. An approach is proposed that starts as a CZM in which the cohesive traction separation law (TSL) is separated into high-strength (HS) and low-strength (LS) components. The HS part, which is responsible for the mesh requirements of the CZM analysis, is replaced by VCCT. The combined method is
evaluated by analyzing the response of double cantilevered beam specimens. Two specimen layup configurations, [0/90/90/0]3s and [0/90/90/0]9s, are evaluated. The R-curve response from each configuration is determined and applied to the constitutive properties of models built with CZM and with VCCT. The results and computational efficiency of the CZM, VCCT, and combined approaches are compared. The results are indicative that a combined cohesive/VCCT approach can enable progressive failure analyses to retain the computational efficiency of VCCT with the ability of the cohesive elements to capture R-curve effects.