The significance of Cl/P2O5 ratios from lunar samples

The Cl(r)/P2O5 ratios of lunar samples are reported to occur in three groups (Jovanovic and Reed, 1975; etc.). These data have been modeled as representative of three discrete volumes of differentiating magma and correlated with large convection cells and moon-wide heterogeneities. The assumptions inherent to their model are not valid. That the Cl(r)/P2O5 ratio of apatite or a rock is indicative of a magma system is unrealistic. A range of ratios can be generated during the fractionation of a magma. Apatite is not the major Cl- and P-bearing phase in most of the samples analyzed; rust, FeO(OH, Cl) and schreibersite, (FeNi)3P, occur in over 2/3 rds of the Apollo 16 rocks where they constitute 0.1-0.6 modal %, enough to account for most of the Cl(r) and P2O5 analyzed. Due to the complexities and presence of these minerals in soils and breccias, Cl(r)/P2O5 ratios have no real significance in non-igneous samples. However, basaltic rocks alone do not define any statistically significant Cl(r)P2O5 groupings.