Static and damage tolerance tests of an advanced composite vertical fin for L-1011 aircraft

This paper recounts the significant events which took place during the structural verification testing of two graphite/epoxy material, full-size vertical stabilizers. The ground test articles were tested to a high bending dynamic lateral gust condition. The first unit failed during static testing at 98 percent Design Ultimate Load. Failure began within the front spar cap. A detailed review of the failure was performed to identify all possible modes. This review resulted in a 'production line' type fix being designed for incorporation in the second ground test article prior to installation in the test fixture. The modified second unit sustained 106 percent of Design Ultimate Load without incident. One lifetime (36,000 flights) of damage tolerance testing was accomplished with the specimen purposely damaged at five locations. A fail-safe loading was performed successfully after simulating lightning strike damage to the fin box cover. A large area repair was substantiated by completing a second lifetime of spectrum loadings. The residual static strength was determined to be 119.7 percent of Design Ultimate Load.