Effects of the law for nongravitational forces on the precession model of comet Encke

The precession model for P/Encke formulated by Whipple and Sekanina (1979) is reexamined in the light of the recent measurements of the OH and H production rates. An optimized precession solution derived using the production law of A'Hearn et al. (1985) is shown to require unacceptably small nucleus dimensions and to offer an inferior fit to observed variations in the orientation of the comet's perihelion fan-shaped coma. Observed changes in the emission fan suggest that both the thrust on the nucleus exerted by unit mass of sublimating ice and the average lag in outgassing are substantially greater before than after perihelion. It is concluded that at this time the Whipple-Sekanina model remains the best available precession solution for this comet.