An experimental study of the aerodynamic characteristics of planar and non-planar outboard wing planforms

A series of wind tunnel experiments have been conducted to investigate the aerodynamic characteristics of several planar and nonplanar wingtip planforms. Seven different configurations: base-line rectangular, elliptical, swept and tapered, swept and tapered with dihedral, swept and tapered with anhedral, rising arc, and drooping arc, were investigated for two different spans. The data are available in terms of coefficient plots of force data, flow visualization photographs, and velocity and pressure flowfield surveys. All planforms, particularly the nonplanar, have some advantages over the baseline rectangular planform. Span efficiencies up to 20-percent greater than baseline are a possibility. However, it is suggested that the span efficiency concept might need refinement for nonplanar wings. Flow survey data show the change in effective span with vortex roll-up. The flow visualization shows the occurrence of mushroom-cell-separation flow patterns at angles of attack corresponding to stall. These grow with an increase in post-stall angle of attack. For the larger aspect ratios, the cells are observed to split into sub-cells at the higher angles of attack. For all angles of attack, some amount of secondary vortex flow is observed for the planar and nonplanar out-board planforms with sweep and taper.