Metal with anomalously low Ni and Ge concentrations in the Allan Hills A77081 winonaite

The Ge content of metal in the Allan Hills A77081 winonaite was determined by high-sensitivity electron microprobe analysis. By optimizing analytical conditions for Ge determination, a detection limit of about 75 ppm could be achieved. In A77081 some small kamacite grains contain less Ni and Ge and more Co than coarse-grained metal. These small grains are always associated with sulfide, raising the possibility that anomalous metal is related to eutectic melting. However, when published partition coefficients for Ni and Ge in the Fe-Ni-S system are used to model fractionation of these elements during eutectic melting, one finds that secondary metal should be enriched in Ni and depleted in Ge. Thus, the positive Ni-Ge correlation found in this study is the opposite of the expected trend. No explanation for this discrepancy has yet been found. Nonetheless, the existence of anomalous metal is an indication that A77081, and probably other winonaites as well, have undergone some fractionation. This supports the notion that the high-temperature history of winonaites is related to the formation of IAB iron meteorites, whose silicate inclusions are very similar to winonaites.