Comments on the photospheric dynamo model of Henoux and Somov

A detailed model for a photospheric dynamo has been presented by Henoux and Somov (1987), who used the three-fluid model to treat the properties of the weakly ionized plasma. Only the equations for the two ionized components were solved. The equation for the neutral component is considered, and it is argued that the model is unacceptable becaused of an implied impossibly large unbalanced stress on the neutral gas. It is argued more generally that all existing photospheric dynamo models are untenable.