Investigation of Vortex Breakdown on a Delta Wing Using Euler and Navier-Stokes Equations

A numerical investigation of leading-edge vortex breakdown on a delta wing at high angles of attack is presented. The analysis has been restricted to low speed flows on a flat plate wing with sharp leading edges. Both Euler and Navier-Stokes (assuming fully laminar and fully turbulent flows) equations have been used in this study and the results are compared against experimental data. Predictions of vortex breakdown progression with angle of attack with both Euler and Navier-Stokes equations are shown to be consistent with the experimental data. However, the Navier-Stokes predictions show significant improvements in breakdown location at angles of attack where the vortex breakdown approaches the wing apex.

The location of the primary vortex and the level of vorticity in the pre-breakdown regions in these flowfield solutions are affected very little by the viscous effects, even though the Navier-Stokes solutions exhibit viscous phenomena such as secondary and tertiary vortices which are not present in the Euler solutions. In the post-breakdown regions, however, the levels of vorticity in the primary vortex have increased differences between the Euler and Navier-Stokes solutions at comparable locations. Navier-Stokes indicates the presence of a secondary vortex even after the primary vortex is burst. The predicted trajectories of the primary vortex are in very good agreement with the test data, the laminar solutions providing the overall best comparison. The Euler shows a small displacement of the primary vortex, relative to experiment, due to the lack of secondary vortices. The turbulent Navier-Stokes, in general, fall between the Euler and laminar solutions. These findings are based on solutions from meshes that are not usually considered fine enough for resolving vortical flows. To further understand the vortex breakdown phenomenon and the fine details of the vortical flow structure, further calculations with the finer meshes and improved turbulence models are necessary.