Asteroidal versus cometary meteoroid impacts on the Long Duration Exposure Facility (LDEF)

Meteoroids that enter the Earth's atmosphere at low velocities will tend to impact the apex side (that surface facing the spacecraft direction of motion) of a spacecraft at a very high rate compared to the rate with which they will impact an antapex-facing surface. This ratio -- apex to antapex impact rates -- will become less as meteoroid entry velocities increase. The measured ratio, apex to antapex, for 500 micron diameter impact craters in 6061-T6 aluminum on LDEF seems to be about 20 from the work of the meteoroid SIG group and from the work of Humes that was presented at the first LDEF symposium. Such a ratio is more consistent with the meteoroid velocity distributions derived by Erickson and by Kessler, than it is with others that have been tested. These meteoroid velocity distributions have mean entry velocities into the Earth's atmosphere of 16.5 to 16.9 km/s. Jackson and Zook (in a paper submitted to Icarus) have numerically simulated the orbital evolution of small dust grains emitted from asteroids and comets. For those asteroidal grains small enough (below about 100 microns diameter) to drift from the asteroid belt to the orbit of the Earth, under P-R and solar wind drag, without suffering collisional destruction, the following results are found: as their ascending or descending nodes cross the Earth's orbit (and when they might collide with the Earth), their orbital eccentricities and inclinations are quite low (e less than 0.3, i less than 20 degrees), and their mean velocity with respect to the Earth is about 5 or 6 km/s. When gravitational acceleration of the Earth is taken into account, the corresponding mean velocities relative to the top of the Earth's atmosphere are 12 to 13 km/s. This means that, at best, these small asteroidal particles can not comprise more than 50 percent of the particles entering the Earth's atmosphere. And when gravitational focusing is considered, they cannot comprise more than a few percent of those in heliocentric orbit at 1 AU. The rest are presumably of cometary origin.