Comparison of the Unified Perturbation Method with the two-scale expansion

The Unified Perturbation Method (UPM) converges faster over a wider domain of surface roughness than other perturbations, such as the small perturbation method, the phase perturbation method, the Kirchhoff approximation, and the momentum transfer expansion. It can be shown that UPM intrinsically possess characteristics similar to the two-scale expansion without requiring a free parameter. This paper considers whether the UPM can be improved by applying the two-scale concept to the method. In order to do so, the unknown source current is expanded in a two-scale manner starting from the extinction theorem. Several two-scale expansions are derived and are compared with the conventional two-scale approximation. It is shown that the UPM performs best without two-scale expansions.