Comment on 'Geomagnetic activity associated with earth passage of interplanetary shock disturbances and coronal mass ejections' by J. T. Gosling, D. J. McComas, J. L. Philips, and S. J. Bame

It is contended that statistical data do not support the claim of Gosling et al. (1991) to the effect that the initial speed of a solar wind driver gas close to the sun appears to be the most crucial factor in determining if an earthward direct event will be effective in exciting a large geomagnetic disturbance. It is argued that the time intervals are much too large to observe the storm-time B sub Z dependence. Gosling et al. reply that this comment is based on a serious misunderstanding of their conclusions.