HL-20 structural design comparison - Conformal shell versus cylindrical crew compartment

Extensive studies have been performed at NASA Langley Research Center (LaRC) on personnel launch systems (PLS) concepts. The primary mission of a PLS is the transport of Space Station crew members from Earth to the Space Station and return. The NASA LaRC PLS studies have led to the design of a lifting body configuration named the HL-20. In this study, two different HL-20 structural configurations are evaluated. The two configurations are deemed the conformal shell and the cylindrical crew compartment. The configurations are based on two different concerns for maintenance and operations. One configuration allows for access to subsystems while on-orbit from the interior, while the other allows for easy access to the subsystems during ground maintenance and operations. For each concept, the total structural weight required to sustain the applied loads is quantified through a structural evaluation. Structural weight for both configurations is compared along with the particular attributes of each. Analyses of both configurations indicate no appreciable weight or load relief advantage of one concept over the other. Maintainability and operability, therefore become the primary discriminator, leading to a choice of a crew compartment configuration.