The fragmentation of dust in the innermost comae of comets: Possible evidence from ground-based images

Dust particles when released from the nucleus of a comet are entrained in the expanding gas flow created by the vaporization of ices (mainly water ice). Traditional approaches to dusty-gas dynamics in the inner comae of comets consider there to be an initial distribution of dust particle sizes which do not fragment or evaporate. The standard Finson-Probstein model (and subsequent variations) yields a one-to-one-to-one correspondence between the size of a dust particle, its terminal velocity owing to gas drag, and its radiation pressure acceleration which creates the notable cometary dust tail. The comparison of a newly developed dust coma model shows that the typical elongated shapes of isophotes in the dust comae of comets on the scale of greater than 10(exp 4) km from the nucleus requires that the one-to-one-to-one relationship between particle size, terminal velocity and radiation pressure acceleration cannot in general be correct. There must be a broad range of particles including those having a small velocity but large radiation pressure acceleration in order to explain the elongated shape. A straightforward way to create such a distribution is if particle fragmentation, or some combination of fragmentation with vaporization, routinely occurs within and/or just outside of the dusty-gas dynamic acceleration region (i.e., up to several hundred km). In this way initially large particles, which are accelerated to fairly slow velocities by gas-drag, fragment to form small particles which still move slowly but are subject to a relatively large radiation pressure acceleration. Fragmentation has already been suggested as one possible interpretation for the flattened gradient in the spatial profiles of dust extracted from Giotto images of Comet Halley. Grain vaporization has been suggested as a possible spatially extended source of coma gases. The general elongated isophote shapes seen in ground-based images for many years represents another possible signature of fragmentation.